|
When a nursing home resident develops a fever, stops eating, becomes confused, or has trouble breathing, the decision to send that resident to the hospital can change the outcome. Families trust that the decision will be made for medical reasons. A new investigation by the State of Texas asks whether, in some cases, money played a role. On October 5, 2026, the Texas Attorney General announced that his office had issued Civil Investigative Demands to UnitedHealth Group. According to the Attorney General's press release, the demands seek evidence of possible violations of the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act ("DTPA") and other Texas laws. The release cites reports alleging that the company "bribed nursing homes to delay hospitalizing patients." These are allegations. No court or agency has found that UnitedHealth or any nursing home did anything wrong, and UnitedHealth did not respond to a request for comment from Healthcare Dive. Still, the investigation raises a question every family with a loved one in a nursing home should be able to answer: what does Texas law require a nursing home to do when a resident's condition changes, and what happens when the facility waits too long? What Is the Texas Attorney General Investigating? The Attorney General issued Civil Investigative Demands to UnitedHealth Group on October 5, 2026, to gather evidence of possible DTPA violations. The press release cites reports that the company paid nursing homes to delay hospitalizing patients, and it describes a Texas patient whose approved procedure was later denied coverage. None of these allegations has been proven. A Civil Investigative Demand is an investigative tool. It requires a company to produce documents or information so the government can decide whether to take further action. It is not a lawsuit, and it is not a finding of wrongdoing. The press release describes a patient who received a letter from UnitedHealth approving a procedure at a surgery center in Austin. After the procedure, the company sent a second letter withdrawing that approval and leaving the patient with a large bill. The Attorney General also argues that the company's coverage decisions may amount to the corporate practice of medicine, meaning that a corporation, rather than a physician, is directing patient care. The release does not identify the reports it relies on. Healthcare Dive reported that UnitedHealth already faces scrutiny from federal investigators and members of Congress from both parties over Medicare billing and nursing home care, and that the Attorney General opened a separate investigation into Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas in late September. What Did Earlier Reports Say About Payments to Nursing Homes? In May 2025, The Guardian reported that UnitedHealth paid nursing homes bonuses tied to keeping hospital admissions low for residents enrolled in its Institutional Special Needs Plans ("I-SNPs"). UnitedHealth denied wrongdoing and sued The Guardian for defamation, but a Delaware judge dismissed that lawsuit in July 2026. An I-SNP is a type of Medicare Advantage plan designed for people who live in nursing homes. According to Skilled Nursing News, The Guardian reported that the payments were tied to low hospital admission rates, that some residents with serious symptoms were not promptly sent to the hospital, and that families were not told about the financial incentives. The company told Skilled Nursing News that the United States Department of Justice ("DOJ") had reviewed the matter and declined to pursue it. According to Becker's Payer Issues, the Delaware judge who dismissed the defamation lawsuit found the reporting on the bonuses "substantially true." The Attorney General's release does not say whether his office is relying on that reporting. UnitedHealth Group has not, in the public sources located as of October 19, 2026, issued a substantive response to the Texas Attorney General's announced investigation. It told KXAN on October 5 that it had no response to share. The company previously denied the underlying nursing-home allegations in a May 21, 2025 statement, asserting that its employees did not prevent hospital transfers, that its approval was not required for hospitalization, and that nursing-facility payments were tied in part to quality measures. When Must a Texas Nursing Home Notify a Doctor About a Change in a Resident's Condition? Federal and Texas rules require a nursing home to immediately inform the resident, consult the resident's physician, and notify the resident's representative when a resident has an accident with injury, a significant change in condition, or a need for a significant change in treatment, or when the facility decides to transfer the resident. Nursing homes that participate in Medicare or Medicaid must follow the federal regulations at 42 CFR §483. The Texas licensing law for nursing facilities is Texas Health and Safety Code Chapter 242. The notification duty appears in 42 CFR §483.10, at paragraph (g)(14), and in its Texas counterpart, 26 Texas Administrative Code §554.403, at subsection (l). Both rules use nearly identical language. A facility must act when there is:
A separate duty governs the care itself. Under 42 CFR §483.25 and the Texas quality of care rule, 26 Texas Administrative Code §554.901, a facility must ensure that each resident receives treatment and care "in accordance with professional standards of practice." Neither the federal rules nor the Texas rules contain an exception based on a resident's insurance plan or on any payment arrangement between an insurer and a facility. Can a Nursing Home Be Held Responsible for Not Sending My Parent to the Hospital? Yes, when the facility's delay falls below accepted standards of care and causes harm. A nursing home that fails to recognize a serious change in a resident's condition, fails to consult the physician, or fails to arrange hospital care when the resident needs it can be held responsible for the injuries that follow. Many of the conditions nursing home residents face are time sensitive. Sepsis can progress quickly from an infection that responds to treatment to organ failure. A stroke left untreated can cause permanent disability. Respiratory distress, internal bleeding, and fractures after a fall all require prompt evaluation. In each of these situations, hours can matter, and a delayed diagnosis can turn a treatable problem into a catastrophic one. When a family believes a nursing home waited too long, the questions in a legal investigation are concrete. When did the change in condition first appear? Did the nursing staff document it and report it? When was the physician consulted, and what did the physician order? Was the family notified? What caused the delay? If an insurer's financial arrangement with the facility influenced the decision, that becomes part of the story as well. Your attorney obtains and reviews the resident's chart, staffing information, and facility policies as part of the case. When a delay contributes to a resident's death, the Texas Wrongful Death Act, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.002, allows certain family members to bring a claim, and the Texas survival statute, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.021, preserves the claims the resident had before death. Our wrongful death page explains more about how these claims work. What Should I Do If I Think a Nursing Home Is Waiting Too Long to Get My Parent Help? If you believe your loved one is facing a medical emergency, call 911. You do not need the facility's permission to request emergency help. After the emergency has passed, you can report your concerns to the state and talk with an attorney about what happened.
We Can Help At The Borah Law Firm, PLLC, we only handle medical malpractice cases in Texas, nothing else. As part of our practice, we represent patients and families in cases just like the one discussed in this blog. If you believe a loved one received substandard nursing home care, we can help you understand whether a case exists and what your options are. Contact us today so you can tell us your story. Frequently Asked Questions Can I Make a Nursing Home Send My Mother to the Hospital? If you believe your mother is having a medical emergency, you can call 911 yourself. Federal and Texas rules also require the nursing home to consult her physician and notify her representative when she has a significant change in condition, so you can ask staff directly whether that has happened and what the physician ordered. What Is an Institutional Special Needs Plan? An Institutional Special Needs Plan is a type of Medicare Advantage plan designed for people who live in nursing homes. The plan, rather than traditional Medicare, manages the resident's coverage, and it may have its own clinicians who see residents at the facility. Families can ask the facility and the plan how hospital transfer decisions are made. Does the Texas Investigation Mean UnitedHealth Did Something Wrong? No. A Civil Investigative Demand is a request for information, not a finding. The Attorney General's allegations have not been proven, and UnitedHealth has denied wrongdoing in response to earlier reports about payments to nursing homes. The investigation may or may not lead to further action. About the Author: J.T. Borah is a Texas-licensed medical malpractice attorney and Texas Super Lawyer at The Borah Law Firm, PLLC in Austin, Texas. He has testified before both the Texas House and Senate on patient safety issues and focuses exclusively on medical malpractice cases statewide. About this article: AI writing tools assisted Mr. Borah in drafting this article. All legal analysis reflects his independent professional judgment. This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Link: https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/news/releases/attorney-general-ken-paxton-investigates-unitedhealth-group-denying-patients-coverage-they-need-and Surgical Never Events in Texas: Can You Sue After a Wrong-Site Surgery or a Retained Sponge?10/23/2026
A Grand Prairie woman went to the emergency room with abdominal pain she assumed was appendicitis. A CT scan showed a curved piece of metal inside her abdomen. When a surgeon removed it, she found a suture needle still sealed in its original packaging. It had presumably been left behind during a cesarean section nearly three years earlier. That account is one of several in a Dallas Morning News investigation published October 20, 2026, into what hospitals call “never events.” The surgical versions are the wrong procedure, the wrong patient, the wrong site, and an object unintentionally left inside the body. According to The News, Texas hospitals and surgery centers report around 200 errors in these four categories each year. Patient safety advocates told the paper the real number is likely higher. The investigation also documented a hard truth. Under Texas law, an error that should never happen does not guarantee a path to the courthouse. What Is a Never Event in Surgery? A never event is a serious and largely preventable medical error that patient safety organizations agree should not happen, and in surgery the category covers operating on the wrong body site, operating on the wrong patient, performing the wrong procedure, and leaving a sponge, needle, or other object inside a patient after an operation. The formal list comes from the National Quality Forum (“NQF”), which publishes its List of Serious Reportable Events. Texas builds that list into state law. Under Texas Health and Safety Code §98.1045, health care facilities must report preventable adverse events to the state, including events on the NQF list and conditions for which the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (“CMS”) will not pay extra. The Dallas Morning News described cases in each surgical category:
Why Do Wrong-Site and Wrong-Patient Surgeries Still Happen in Texas Hospitals? Most surgical never events happen not because of a single careless person but because several safety checks fail at once, such as a missing chart, an erased surgical site marking, a rushed or incomplete time out, or an operating room culture in which nurses and technicians do not feel free to question the surgeon. Experts quoted by The News point to psychology professor James Reason's “Swiss cheese” model. Each safeguard is a slice of cheese. A never event happens when the holes in every slice line up. The most important safeguard is the surgical time out. The Joint Commission's Universal Protocol, in effect since 2004, requires a time out before surgery begins, a pause designed to prevent wrong-site, wrong-procedure, and wrong-person surgery. In the Houston sterilization case, the surgeon later testified that he could not find the patient's chart before the operation and relied on a screen summary that turned out to be inaccurate, according to The News. His surgical note stated that the team conducted a time out and that no one corrected him. Federal hospital rules address the same risk. The CMS Conditions of Participation for hospitals, at 42 CFR §482.51, require that “a properly executed informed consent form for the operation must be in the patient's chart before surgery,” except in emergencies. In Texas, hospitals are licensed under Texas Health and Safety Code Chapter 241 and must follow the state's hospital functions and services rules at 26 Texas Administrative Code §505.41. Can I Sue a Texas Hospital If a Surgeon Operated on the Wrong Site or Left Something Inside Me? Yes, a patient harmed by a wrong-site surgery, a wrong-patient procedure, the wrong procedure, or a retained surgical object can often bring a medical malpractice claim in Texas, but the claim still has to prove that the error caused real harm, and state damages caps limit how much the patient can recover. Never events stand apart from most malpractice cases because the error itself is often less open to debate. When a surgeon removes the wrong tumor, it is far more difficult for a Defendant to argue that the care met the standard of a reasonably careful provider. Responsibility often reaches beyond the surgeon. Sponge, needle, and instrument counts are generally shared work for the circulating nurse and the scrub technician, and the time out involves the entire team. Depending on who employed each person in the room, a claim may involve the surgeon, nursing staff, the hospital, an ambulatory surgery center, or several of them. The harder questions usually concern harm. A Plaintiff must show what the error actually cost, such as added surgeries, lost fertility, pain, lost income, and medical bills. A wrong-site lumpectomy that leaves cancer behind can function much like a delayed diagnosis, because the disease progresses while the patient believes it is gone. Causation can be contested even when the error is not. In the San Antonio wrong-patient case, the woman later died during heart surgery at a different hospital. Her daughters told The News they will never know whether the earlier mix-up contributed to her death. When a surgical error does cause a death, the family's claim may proceed under the Texas Wrongful Death Act, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.002, which our wrongful death page discusses in more detail. How Do Texas Damages Caps Affect a Surgical Error Lawsuit? Texas limits the noneconomic damages a malpractice patient can recover, meaning compensation for pain, mental anguish, and lost quality of life, to $250,000 against all physicians and other individual providers combined, plus up to $250,000 against each liable health care institution, with a $500,000 combined limit for all institutions. Those limits come from Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §74.301, enacted in 2003. Economic damages, such as past and future medical expenses and lost earnings, fall outside the §74.301 caps, although wrongful death and survival cases carry a separate overall limit under §74.303. Plaintiffs' attorneys told The News that, in practice, many patients have access to only one $250,000 category, which is absolutely true. The §74.301 caps are fixed dollar amounts that have not changed since 2003. By the paper's calculation, $250,000 today goes about as far as $140,000 did in 2003. Public hospitals present a separate barrier. According to The News, claims against county hospitals such as Parkland Memorial Hospital in Dallas and JPS Hospital in Fort Worth fall under a different law. The Texas Tort Claims Act limits a local government unit's liability to $100,000 per person for bodily injury or death under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §101.023(b). That limit applies to all money damages, economic and noneconomic alike. The News described a Houston mother whose cesarean section at a county hospital left an infected sponge in her abdomen. She and her family said five or six attorneys turned them away before one took the case. If it proceeds, it will be subject to the $100,000 limit. The legislative debate is not over. The News reported that a bill to tie the $250,000 cap to inflation has been filed in at least the past five legislative sessions, most recently in 2025, and that the current sponsor plans to file it again. Groups that supported the 2003 reforms, including the Texas Alliance for Patient Access and the Texas Medical Association, do not support indexing the cap, according to the paper. Why Do Lawyers Turn Down Surgical Error Cases in Texas? Many Texas lawyers decline surgical never event cases because the damages caps can leave too little recovery to cover the expert witnesses, litigation costs, and fees a malpractice case requires, a problem that falls hardest on retirees and lower-wage workers whose claims depend mostly on capped noneconomic damages. The numbers in the investigation are sobering. The News analyzed a national dataset of malpractice payments made on behalf of practitioners and found that, from 2015 to 2025, the median payment in surgical never event cases was about $58,000 and the average was about $103,000. Payments made only on behalf of hospitals are not in that dataset. That does not make these cases hopeless. Because economic damages fall outside the §74.301 caps, and because a second liable institution raises the noneconomic limit, the cases most likely to move forward tend to involve substantial future medical care, lost earning capacity, or more than one responsible health care institution. Sorting that out requires a careful review of the medical records, which is work the attorney handles after being retained. Our surgical error page explains more about how these cases are evaluated. We Can Help At The Borah Law Firm, PLLC, we only handle medical malpractice cases in Texas, nothing else. As part of our practice, we represent patients and families in cases just like the one discussed in this blog. If you believe a loved one received substandard surgical care, we can help you understand whether a case exists and what your options are. Contact us today so you can tell us your story. Frequently Asked Questions Is leaving a sponge inside a patient after surgery considered malpractice in Texas? A sponge, needle, or instrument left inside a patient is one of the NQF's serious reportable events, and it can support a Texas medical malpractice claim when it causes harm. The strength of the claim usually depends on what the retained object led to, such as infection, additional surgery, or lasting injury, and on which providers were responsible for the surgical count. Who is responsible if a hospital operates on the wrong patient? Responsibility can fall on the surgeon, on the nurses and other team members involved in verifying the patient, and on the hospital or surgery center, depending on who employed each person. The Joint Commission's Universal Protocol requires a time out before surgery begins precisely to prevent wrong-person, wrong-site, and wrong-procedure surgery. How much can I recover for a surgical error in Texas? The answer depends on your economic losses and on who is responsible. Medical bills and lost earnings are not limited by the §74.301 caps, but noneconomic damages are capped at $250,000 against physicians and other individual providers combined, plus up to $250,000 per health care institution, with a $500,000 institutional limit. Claims against many county hospitals face a $100,000 limit on all damages. Link: https://www.yahoo.com/news/us/articles/wrong-operation-wrong-patient-hundreds-110000095.html About the Author: J.T. Borah is a Texas-licensed medical malpractice attorney and Texas Super Lawyer at The Borah Law Firm, PLLC in Austin, Texas. He has testified before both the Texas House and Senate on patient safety issues and focuses exclusively on medical malpractice cases statewide. About this article: AI writing tools assisted Mr. Borah in drafting this article. All legal analysis reflects his independent professional judgment. This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. A nursing home is supposed to be the place where a frail or aging loved one is kept safe. For a number of families across the country, it has instead become the place where a fellow resident, not a stranger off the street, caused fatal or permanently disabling harm. A KFF Health News investigation published by NPR on July 19, 2026, documented case after case in which residents with dementia attacked roommates and neighbors, sometimes with lethal results, after staff had already been warned that trouble was coming. None of the incidents in that reporting occurred in Texas, but the legal duties the reporting exposes, the duty to screen incoming residents, the duty to act on warning signs, and the duty to supervise residents who pose a known risk, apply with equal force to every nursing home and assisted living facility licensed in this state. Why Do Residents With Dementia Sometimes Attack Other Residents? Dementia can damage the brain circuits that govern impulse control and threat perception, and pain, infection, or unmet needs a resident cannot put into words can surface instead as shouting, grabbing, or hitting. According to the reporting, residents with Alzheimer's disease and other dementias make up more than 900,000 of the 2.2 million people living in nursing homes and assisted living facilities nationwide, and researchers have found that residents who become physically aggressive toward others are disproportionately likely to have dementia. A Cornell University study of 14 New York assisted living facilities estimated that roughly 1 in 7 residents experienced some form of aggression in a given month, and a related Cornell study of 10 New York nursing homes estimated roughly 1 in 5 residents experienced an altercation in a month. A separate analysis of federal survey data found that nearly 8 percent of assisted living residents engaged in physical aggression toward another resident or a staff member. According to KFF Health News' review of federal inspection reports, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services ("CMS") has cited nursing homes at least 700 times since the start of 2024 for failing to protect residents from abuse by other residents, and in the first three months of 2026, resident-on-resident abuse was cited more often than any other category of abuse, neglect, or exploitation. These are not freak occurrences. They are a documented and recurring pattern in long-term care. Who Is Responsible When One Nursing Home Resident Injures Another? A nursing home or assisted living facility is responsible when it knew, or reasonably should have known, that a resident posed a risk to others and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent harm. Federal law requires every Medicare and Medicaid certified nursing home to protect each resident's right to be free from abuse and neglect, including abuse committed by other residents, under 42 CFR §483.12. Texas nursing facilities are separately licensed and regulated under Texas Health and Safety Code Chapter 242, and assisted living facilities under Texas Health and Safety Code Chapter 247, both of which impose licensing, staffing, and resident-protection obligations that run parallel to the federal rule. In the case reported by KFF Health News of Attilio Cecchetto, a 92-year-old resident of a California facility, staff had already moved his eventual killer, a resident with a documented history of violent felony convictions and a known intolerance of noise, through eight room changes in four months before placing him with Mr. Cecchetto. California regulators fined the facility $120,000, and CMS separately fined it $62,810, for failing to account for that resident's articulated dislike of noise when assigning his room. The facility's owner has denied negligence and disputes the fine. A wrongful death lawsuit is pending against the corporate ownership group. Facilities that know about a resident's history of aggression, whether from prior incidents, staff reports, or family warnings, and place that resident near a vulnerable roommate anyway, are the ones most exposed to a negligence claim. On What Warning Signs Should a Nursing Home Act? A facility should act when staff report escalating agitation, when a resident repeatedly enters another resident's room or space, or when a resident has a documented history of striking, biting, or threatening others. In the Minnesota case reported by KFF Health News, aides at a memory care unit had already told a resident's doctor it was "only a matter of time before" she "hurts another resident," and the victim's daughter had separately warned the facility in writing after her mother's webcam repeatedly showed the same resident entering her mother's room. Days later, that resident pushed 96 year old Gladys Lynch to the floor. Ms. Lynch suffered a brain hemorrhage and fractures to her eye socket and ribs, and she died five days later. Minnesota regulators concluded the facility was responsible for neglect because it knew about the danger and failed to put effective interventions in place. Geriatric researchers and dementia specialists recommend concrete responses to warning signs like these: closer supervision, moving a high-risk resident nearer to the nursing station, separating residents who have already clashed, adjusting roommate and seating assignments, and in more serious situations, one-on-one supervision or evaluation at a hospital or psychiatric facility. A facility's own incident reports, care plan notes, and staffing records, which a resident or family member has a right to request, often show whether these steps were taken or ignored. Can a Texas Nursing Home Be Held Liable for a Resident-on-Resident Assault? Yes, a Texas nursing home or assisted living facility can be held liable when its own negligence, in screening, supervision, staffing, or its response to known warning signs, contributed to one resident injuring another. Claims of this kind are typically brought as health care liability claims under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Chapter 74, which carries specific procedural requirements a family and their attorney must satisfy. Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §74.351 requires a Claimant asserting a health care liability claim to serve a preliminary expert report on each Defendant within 120 days of the date on which that Defendant filed their Answer to a lawsuit. This preliminary expert report is required to explain the standard of care, how it was breached, and how the breach caused the injury based on the information then available. When a resident-on-resident assault results in death, as it did in both the California and Minnesota cases described above, a family may also have claims under the Texas Wrongful Death Act, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.002, and the Texas survival statute, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.021. Regulatory findings can matter a great deal in these cases. A CMS or Texas Health and Human Services Commission ("HHSC") citation finding that a facility's failure caused or was likely to place a resident in Immediate Jeopardy of serious harm, as regulators found in both the California and Minnesota incidents, is not itself a damages award, but it can be significant evidence of what the facility knew and when it knew it. What Should Families Do If a Loved One Is Injured by Another Resident? Families should document the injury, request the facility's incident report and the resident's care plan and staffing notes in writing, and preserve any video, photographs, or written warnings they gave the facility before the assault occurred. In the Minnesota case, the victim's daughter had installed a web camera and had emailed the facility a written list of concerns weeks before her mother was killed, and those records became central to the state's neglect finding. Families should also contact their state's long-term care ombudsman and, where the facility is federally certified, request a copy of any CMS inspection findings related to the incident. Because health care liability claims in Texas move on a strict procedural clock, including the expert report deadline described above, families should not wait to speak with an attorney who focuses on nursing home and assisted living negligence cases. We Can Help The Borah Law Firm, PLLC, we only handle medical malpractice cases in Texas, nothing else. As part of our practice, we represent patients and families in cases just like the ones discussed in this blog. If you believe a loved one was injured or killed by another resident in a nursing home or assisted living facility, we can help you understand whether a case exists and what your options are. Contact us today so you can tell us your story. Frequently Asked Questions Can a nursing home be sued if one resident injures another resident? Yes, a nursing home can be sued if its own negligence in screening, supervision, staffing, or response to known warning signs contributed to the injury. A facility is not automatically liable simply because two residents with dementia had a conflict, since some altercations happen despite reasonable precautions. Liability turns on what the facility knew about the risk and what it did, or failed to do, in response. What does Immediate Jeopardy mean on a nursing home inspection report? Immediate Jeopardy is the most serious classification a federal or Texas HHSC inspector can assign, meaning a facility's noncompliance caused, or was likely to cause, serious injury, harm, impairment, or death to a resident. An Immediate Jeopardy finding tied to a resident-on-resident incident, like the findings described in this article, can be important evidence in a subsequent negligence claim, though the finding itself is a regulatory determination rather than a damages award. How long do I have to file a nursing home negligence claim in Texas? Texas health care liability claims are generally subject to a strict statute of limitations, and separately require a preliminary expert report under Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §74.351 within 120 days of a Defendant's Answer, so families should not delay in speaking with an attorney once they suspect negligence. Waiting can foreclose access to video, staffing records, and witness accounts that tend to disappear quickly after an incident. About the Author: J.T. Borah is a Texas-licensed medical malpractice attorney and Texas Super Lawyer at The Borah Law Firm, PLLC in Austin, Texas. He has testified before both the Texas House and Senate on patient safety issues and focuses exclusively on medical malpractice cases statewide. About this article: AI writing tools assisted Mr. Borah in drafting this article. All legal analysis reflects his independent professional judgment. This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Link: https://www.npr.org/2026/07/19/nx-s1-5894692/dementia-violence-warning-supervision-nursing-homes-assisted-living-facility It often happens on the third or fourth day. A nurse rolls your father onto his side, and you see it for the first time: a dark purple patch over his tailbone, or an open wound on his heel. When you ask what happened, the answer comes quickly. He must have come in with it. That answer may be true. It may also be false. Hospitals and wound care experts use specific time windows to decide whether a pressure injury, the clinical term for a bedsore, was present when a patient arrived or developed during the hospital stay. A September 2026 literature review in the journal Advances in Skin & Wound Care highlighted a study in which experts reached agreement on those windows. The federal government already uses similar timing to measure harm in hospitals. What Is a Hospital-Acquired Pressure Injury? A hospital-acquired pressure injury is damage to the skin and the tissue beneath it that develops during a hospital stay, usually over a bony area such as the tailbone, hips, or heels, because of sustained pressure, often combined with shear, on a patient who cannot easily change position without help. The National Pressure Injury Advisory Panel (“NPIAP”) classifies these injuries by how deep the damage goes:
The NPIAP notes that discoloration may look different in darkly pigmented skin and that pain and temperature changes often come before any visible color change. That matters. An injury that is hard to see is easy to miss. How Do Hospitals Decide Whether a Bedsore Was Present on Admission? Under a federal hospital safety measure, a Stage 2, Stage 3, Stage 4, or unstageable pressure injury first found more than 24 hours after a hospital encounter begins counts as hospital harm, and a deep tissue pressure injury first found more than 72 hours after the encounter begins counts the same way. That measure is the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (“CMS”) Hospital Harm Pressure Injury measure. It also relies on the “present on admission” code that hospitals attach to each diagnosis. Under the measure, an injury coded as not present on admission counts as hospital harm. So does an injury coded with documentation insufficient to tell. An injury coded as present on admission, or as clinically undetermined, does not. The September 2026 review in Advances in Skin & Wound Care described a study in which experts, after three rounds of voting, agreed that Stage 2, Stage 3, and Stage 4 injuries developing more than 24 hours after admission should be considered hospital-acquired. For deep tissue and unstageable injuries, the experts required 72 hours. The two approaches differ on one point. CMS applies the 24-hour window to unstageable injuries, while the expert panel placed them in the 72-hour group. Why does this matter to a family? The 24-hour mark puts real weight on the skin assessment done at arrival. A hospital that did not document the skin on the first day may struggle to show that a wound came from somewhere else. Why Do Deep Tissue Injuries Get a 72-Hour Window? Deep tissue injuries get a longer window because the damage begins beneath the skin, and CMS explains that 24 to 72 hours can pass between the pressure that causes the injury and the first appearance of purple or maroon skin, so a mark seen on the second day may have started before admission. That cuts both ways. A patient who lays on the floor at home for hours before help arrived may come to the hospital with a deep tissue injury that has not surfaced yet. A deep tissue injury that first appears on the fifth or sixth day of a hospital stay is much harder to blame on anything that happened before admission. The NPIAP also warns that a deep tissue injury may develope rapidly to reveal the actual extent of the damage. Prompt recognition and treatment matter. Is a Hospital Bedsore Always a Sign of Negligence? No, a hospital bedsore is not automatically proof of negligence, because some patients develop pressure injuries despite good care, but many are preventable, and the legal question in Texas is whether the hospital and its staff followed accepted standards for assessing risk, inspecting skin, repositioning the patient, and responding when damage appeared. Federal rules require every hospital that participates in Medicare to maintain an organized nursing service that provides 24-hour nursing care, with enough nurses to meet patient needs and a current nursing care plan for each patient, under 42 CFR §482.23. Texas sets its own minimum standards for hospitals through the Texas Health and Safety Code Chapter 241 and the state hospital licensing rule on hospital functions and services at 26 Texas Administrative Code §505.41. Federal payment rules also treat serious hospital pressure injuries as preventable. Under the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005, CMS identified hospital-acquired conditions that could reasonably have been prevented through evidence-based guidelines. Stage III and IV pressure ulcers, the term CMS uses, are on that list. Since October 1, 2008, hospitals have not received additional Medicare payment for those injuries when they were not present on admission. Texas ties its own reporting system to that federal list. Under Texas Health and Safety Code §98.1045, health care facilities must report to the Texas Department of State Health Services (“DSHS”) any adverse condition for which Medicare will not provide additional payment, along with certain events identified by the National Quality Forum (“NQF”). CMS notes that the NQF considers pressure injury a serious reportable event. None of these rules decides a lawsuit. A Texas medical malpractice claim still requires proof that the care fell below the accepted standard and caused harm. The stakes can be high. The CMS measure lists local infection, bone infection, anemia, and sepsis among the complications pressure injuries commonly cause. When a patient dies from those complications, certain family members may bring a wrongful death claim under the Texas Wrongful Death Act, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.002, and the patient’s estate may pursue the patient’s own claim under the Texas survival statute, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.021. What Happens When the Hospital Blames the Nursing Home? When a hospital says a pressure injury came from a nursing home, or a nursing home says it came from the hospital, the answer usually turns on timing and documentation, including when the skin was first examined, what each facility recorded at transfer, and whether the stage of the wound fits each side’s timeline. Older patients often move between hospitals, rehabilitation units, and nursing homes within days. Each handoff creates a chance for a wound to go unnoticed, and for each facility to point at the other. Sorting out those competing stories is part of the work a medical malpractice attorney handles. The attorney gathers the records from every facility involved, and qualified medical experts compare the documented skin findings against the 24-hour and 72-hour windows and the NPIAP staging definitions. Families should not have to do that detective work on their own. What Can Families Watch for During a Hospital Stay? Families can watch for redness that does not fade, purple or maroon patches, blisters, or new pain over the tailbone, hips, or heels, and they can ask the nurses whether a skin assessment was done on admission, how often the patient is being turned, and what pressure-relieving mattress or cushions are in use. If something looks wrong, tell the charge nurse and ask that the wound care team evaluate it. Many pressure injuries trace back to nursing negligence, such as missed turning schedules or skin checks that never happened. Speaking up early can change the outcome. It also helps to keep simple notes of your own: the date you first noticed a change, who you spoke with, and what you were told. Those notes can help an attorney understand the timeline later. The 24-hour and 72-hour rules do not settle who is at fault. They do give families a fair question to ask when a hospital says a wound was there all along: was it documented within the window, or was it found later? We Can Help At The Borah Law Firm, PLLC, we only handle medical malpractice cases in Texas, nothing else. As part of our practice, we represent patients and families in cases just like the one discussed in this blog. If you believe a loved one received substandard hospital pressure injury prevention care, we can help you understand whether a case exists and what your options are. Contact us today so you can tell us your story. Frequently Asked Questions Can I Sue a Hospital in Texas if My Parent Got a Bedsore During a Hospital Stay? Yes, a Texas hospital can be held responsible for a pressure injury that developed during a hospital stay if the care fell below accepted standards and that failure caused harm. Not every hospital bedsore results from negligence. The answer depends on the patient’s risk factors, when the injury was first found, and what the nursing staff did or did not do to prevent it. How Long Does It Take for a Bedsore to Show Up After the Damage Starts? A deep tissue pressure injury may not become visible until 24 to 72 hours after the pressure that caused it, according to CMS. The NPIAP notes that pain and temperature changes often come before color changes and that discoloration may look different on darker skin. That delay is why federal measures use a longer window before calling a deep tissue injury hospital-acquired. Does Medicare Pay Hospitals to Treat Bedsores That Start in the Hospital? No, Medicare does not pay hospitals additional money for Stage III or IV pressure ulcers that were not present on admission, a policy that has applied to discharges since October 1, 2008. CMS placed these injuries on its list of hospital-acquired conditions because they could reasonably be prevented through evidence-based guidelines. Link: https://www.ovid.com/jnls/aswcjournal/fulltext/10.1097/asw.0000000000000512~the-2025-update-on-pressure-injuries-a-review-of-selected About the Author: J.T. Borah is a Texas-licensed medical malpractice attorney and Texas Super Lawyer at The Borah Law Firm, PLLC in Austin, Texas. He has testified before both the Texas House and Senate on patient safety issues and focuses exclusively on medical malpractice cases statewide. About this article: AI writing tools assisted Mr. Borah in drafting this article. All legal analysis reflects his independent professional judgment. This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Starting October 8, 2026, families searching for a nursing home on Medicare’s Care Compare website may notice something new: an icon on the profiles of certain facilities. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (“CMS”) calls it the High Performing Facility icon. Advocacy groups have described it as a trophy. That sounds like good news. In Texas, it also raises hard questions. According to preliminary CMS data, only 59 of 1,176 Texas nursing facilities qualified as of June 2026. The icon is also tied to something many families do not expect: a shorter, lighter inspection. What Is Medicare’s New “High Performing Facility” Icon? The High Performing Facility icon is a symbol CMS places on the Care Compare profile of each nursing home that qualifies for its new Risk-Based Survey, a shorter inspection process, and CMS says it identifies homes with quality indicators beyond the traditional five-star rating, such as citation history and staffing levels. CMS announced the program in a July 16, 2026 memo to state survey agencies and revised that memo on September 29, 2026 to move the icon’s public launch to October 8. A facility must meet 11 criteria to qualify. They include a five-star overall rating, a staffing rating of at least three stars, and no citations for actual harm, Immediate Jeopardy, or Substandard Quality of Care in the last survey cycle. How Many Texas Nursing Homes Qualify for the Icon? According to preliminary CMS data as of June 2026, only 59 of the 1,176 Texas nursing facilities in the analysis, about 5 percent, qualified for the Risk-Based Survey and the icon that comes with it, while CMS estimated that roughly 12 percent of nursing homes would qualify nationwide. The same CMS table shows why so many Texas homes fell short. Of those 1,176 Texas facilities:
CMS describes these figures as preliminary and subject to change. Still, the pattern is hard to ignore. Apart from the five-star requirement itself, a low staffing rating was the most common reason Texas facilities failed to qualify. Does the Icon Mean a Nursing Home Gets Inspected Less? A home with the icon is still inspected on the normal federal schedule, but its standard inspection may use the shorter Risk-Based Survey, which CMS says is conducted in roughly half the time, with fewer surveyors and a smaller sample of residents than the traditional inspection process. Under 42 CFR §488.308, the state survey agency must conduct a standard survey of each nursing home within 15 months of the last one, and the statewide average interval must be 12 months or less. Texas adds its own requirement. Under Texas Health and Safety Code §242.044, the Texas Health and Human Services Commission (“HHSC”) must conduct at least one unannounced inspection of each nursing facility every year. CMS says the shorter survey lets states spend limited resources on complaint investigations and on homes where residents face greater risk. It tested the process in 22 states and more than 100 facilities and reported findings comparable to the traditional survey. Not everyone agrees. The National Consumer Voice for Quality Long-Term Care (“Consumer Voice”), a resident advocacy group, wrote that under the new survey, infection control is the only mandatory facility task unless other problems are triggered. It also wrote that areas such as staffing sufficiency and medication errors would be reviewed only if triggered, and that records of residents who died, were discharged, or were hospitalized would no longer be reviewed. McKnight’s Long-Term Care News reported that a senior policy attorney at the Center for Medicare Advocacy argued the shorter survey violates federal law. Can a Nursing Home Lose Its High Performing Status? Yes, a nursing home can lose its high performing status, because CMS reevaluates eligibility every quarter, and a Consumer Voice analysis of earlier CMS data found that only 52 percent of homes meeting the measurable criteria in January 2024 still met them 13 months later, with 20 percent falling out within three months. Consumer Voice could test only 7 of the 11 criteria with public data, so its numbers are an approximation. Losing the five-star overall rating was the most common reason homes dropped out. CMS itself acknowledges a lag. The revised memo states that, because of data processing, the facilities showing the icon on Care Compare will differ from the lists CMS sends to state survey agencies, and it tells states to rely on their lists rather than the website. A facility on the list can also be disqualified before its survey for events such as a new Immediate Jeopardy citation or a pending complaint investigation triaged at that level. Does a High Performing Icon Change a Nursing Home’s Legal Duties? No, the icon does not change a nursing home’s legal duties, because every Medicare and Medicaid certified facility must meet the same federal requirements regardless of its rating, and in Texas a facility that harms a resident through substandard care can be held accountable whether or not it displays the icon on Care Compare. Federal requirements for nursing homes appear in 42 CFR §483, and the federal quality of care standard appears at 42 CFR §483.25. Texas has parallel rules. Texas Health and Safety Code Chapter 242 governs the licensing of nursing facilities, and the Texas “Quality of Care” rule appears at 26 Texas Administrative Code §554.901. An icon summarizes past data. A nursing home negligence claim asks a different question: what happened to this resident, on these dates, and whether the care met the standard. Problems such as pressure injuries, falls, dehydration, and missed medications are judged on the facts of each case. When neglect causes a death, certain family members may bring a wrongful death claim under the Texas Wrongful Death Act, Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code §71.002. How Should Families Use the Icon When Choosing a Texas Nursing Home? Families should treat the icon as one piece of information, not a guarantee, and should also check the home’s current star ratings and recent inspection reports on Care Compare, visit at different times of day, ask about staffing on evenings and weekends, and contact the long-term care ombudsman with any concerns. The revised CMS memo says families will be able to tell whether an inspection was a Risk-Based Survey through a footnote on the Care Compare survey results page and an indicator on the inspection report, known as form CMS-2567. That detail matters. A clean report from a shorter survey may reflect a narrower review. After admission, keep watching. Weight loss, new wounds, unexplained bruises, and repeated falls deserve prompt questions to the director of nursing. These problems can trace back to nursing negligence and short staffing, and they can happen at any facility, including one with an icon on its profile. The icon may help a family start a search. It should not end one. We Can Help At The Borah Law Firm, PLLC, we only handle medical malpractice cases in Texas, nothing else. As part of our practice, we represent patients and families in cases just like the one discussed in this blog. If you believe a loved one received substandard nursing home care, we can help you understand whether a case exists and what your options are. Contact us today so you can tell us your story. Frequently Asked Questions Is a 5-Star Nursing Home Automatically Safe in Texas? No, a five-star rating does not guarantee safe care. Ratings are built from past inspection, staffing, and quality data. In the Consumer Voice analysis, losing the five-star overall rating was involved in about three of every four cases in which a home lost high performing eligibility, which shows how quickly ratings can change. How Often Are Texas Nursing Homes Inspected? Federal rules require a standard survey of each Texas nursing home within 15 months of the last one, with a statewide average of 12 months or less, and Texas law requires HHSC to conduct at least one unannounced inspection of each nursing facility every year. Federal rules also allow surveys as often as necessary, including to investigate complaints. How Can I Tell if a Nursing Home Had a Shorter Inspection? CMS says it will flag Risk-Based Surveys with a footnote on the Care Compare survey results page and an indicator on the inspection report, form CMS-2567. The same information will appear in the survey files in the CMS Provider Data Catalog. Link: https://www.cms.gov/files/document/qso-26-14-nh-revised-2026-09-29.pdf About the Author: J.T. Borah is a Texas-licensed medical malpractice attorney and Texas Super Lawyer at The Borah Law Firm, PLLC in Austin, Texas. He has testified before both the Texas House and Senate on patient safety issues and focuses exclusively on medical malpractice cases statewide. About this article: AI writing tools assisted Mr. Borah in drafting this article. All legal analysis reflects his independent professional judgment. This article is for general informational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
November 2026
Categories |
Contact Us |
E19823942023LUMIN283